Awards and Nominations
2023 Drama Desk Awards
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Play: Kyle Beltran was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Play: Will Brill was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Play: Samuel D. Hunter was nominated but did not win.
2023 Outer Critics Circle Awards
Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play: A Case for the Existence of God was nominated but did not win.
2023 The Lortels
Outstanding Director: David Cromer was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Lead Performer in a Play: Kyle Beltran was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Lighting Design: Tyler Micoleau was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Play: Samuel D. Hunter was nominated but did not win.
Outstanding Scenic Design: Arnulfo Maldonado was nominated but did not win.
2022 New York Drama Critics Circle Awards
Best Play: Samuel D. Hunter won.