When the playwright and director, Moss Hart, published his autobiography, "Act One," in 1959 it was a sensation, filled with vivid recollections of colorful characters, especially Hart's first great collaborator, the brilliant George S. Kaufman.
The book gave a fascinating insider's view of how a show really gets to the stage. Many people feel it has never been bettered. "Act One" was more than just a Broadway tale, though. It was a bestseller for almost a year, topping the New York Times list for 41 weeks. Why would this story of the playwright and director's early years be so wildly and widely popular?
We think it's because "Act One" is not just the ultimate valentine to the theater. It is also a Dickensian story of a young immigrant and his family, struggling to escape poverty in the early 20th century. From tenements to glamorous townhouses, from Buffalo stages to Catskills summer camps, and finally to the Broadway of his dreams, Hart's masterful telling captures the hope, misery and comedy of the climb, but also the glee of making it - because he did! A classic New York story.
Now, almost 75 years after Moss Hart's first Broadway success, James Lapine (who knows a thing or two about collaboration from his many shows written with Stephen Sondheim) brings ACT ONE to the stage. He has written and directs this world premiere production at the Beaumont. Tony Shalhoub, playing both George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart as an adult, is familiar to LCT audiences as the father in Golden Boy for which he was nominated for a Tony Award last season. Santino Fontana (the Tony-nominated prince in Broadway's Cinderella) portrays Mr. Hart as a young man. Andrea Martin (Tony winner for her spectacular turn as Berthe in Pippin, and also for LCT's My Favorite Year) plays Aunt Kate, a pivotal figure in Hart's early life.
Even though 'Act One' could use pruning, there's something missing: It never reveals what made Hart special. Story structure? Colorful characters? Snappy dialogue? The basic fact should be the starting point, but it's missing in action here.
Unfortunately, the production that has actually resulted will likely satisfy neither the acolytes nor the cynics. Act One, the play, is too mild for the former and too credulous for me. Which is not to say it has no charms; charm is nearly all it has. Dozens of scenes, mostly the same length, paint pretty pictures of Hart's life...But this format of narration and illustration, enabled by Beowulf Boritt's gigantic revolving three-story set, is the opposite of dramatic; it's formal and repetitive like a pop-up book, about the last thing you want from Hart's you-go-kid story. The actors strain to connect, but it isn't until near the end of the long evening that any of them are given enough playable conflict to swing at.
2014 | Broadway |
Lincoln Center Production Broadway |
Year | Ceremony | Category | Nominee |
---|---|---|---|
2014 | BroadwayWorld Awards | Best Play | James Lapine |
2014 | Drama Desk Awards | Outstanding Sound Design in a Play | Dan Moses Schreier |
2014 | Drama League Awards | Distinguished Performance Award | Tony Shalhoub |
2014 | Outer Critics Circle Awards | Outstanding Actor in a Play | Tony Shalhoub |
2014 | Outer Critics Circle Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Andrea Martin |
2014 | Outer Critics Circle Awards | Outstanding New Broadway Play | Act One |
2014 | Outer Critics Circle Awards | Outstanding Set Design (Play or Musical) | Beowulf Boritt |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Costume Design of a Play | Jane Greenwood |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play | Tony Shalhoub |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Play | James Lapine |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Play | Lincoln Center Theater |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Play | Andre Bishop |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Play | Adam Siegel |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Play | Hattie K. Jutagir |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Scenic Design of a Play | Beowulf Boritt |
2014 | Tony Awards | Best Sound Design of a Play | Dan Moses Schreier |
Videos