Jay Armstrong Johnson
Most recent Broadway credits: The Phantom of the Opera (2018), Hands on a Hardbody (2013), and Catch Me if You Can (2011). Other Broadway/NY: On The Town (Chip), Most Happy Fella for Encores!
Latest News on Jay Armstrong Johnson:
MS·A
Track Your Shows, Get Recommendations, and More!
Add Jay Armstrong Johnson's shows to your list.
BIO
Most recent Broadway credits: The Phantom of the Opera (2018), Hands on a Hardbody (2013), and Catch Me if You Can (2011). Other Broadway/NY: On The Town (Chip), Most Happy Fella for Encores! (Herman); Sweeney Todd/NY Philharmonic (Anthony); 8 (Spencer), Hands on a Hardbody (Greg), Catch Me If You Can (Frank Jr. Standby), HAIR (Original Revival Cast, Claude U/S). Off-B'way: Working (Drama Desk Award, Prospect Theater Company), Wild Animals You Should Know (MCC). First National Tour: A Chorus Line (Mark). Regional: The Last Goodbye (Romeo), Old Globe; On The Town (Chip), Barrington; Pirates! Gilbert and Sullivan Plunder'd (Frederick), MUNY; Hands On A Hardbody, La Jolla; Pool Boy, Barrington; Hairspray (Link Larkin),Weston Playhouse. 35mm: A Musical Exhibition (on iTunes). TV/Film: Sex & the City 2, "Law & Order: SVU". Vocal Training: Jeremy Aye.
Photos
STAGE CREDITS
[Off-Broadway]
Manhattan Concert Productions Concert, 2020
Reuben
[Off-Broadway]
One Night Only Concert Presentation Production, 2017
Performer
See how Jay Armstrong Johnson connects to other Broadway stars and creatives.
Six Degrees of Broadway Beta
See how many degrees separate Jay Armstrong Johnson from another Broadway star or creative.
Jay Armstrong Johnson
Connection
Movies
Sex and the City 2
[ 2010 ] Wedding Chorus
[ 2010 ] Wedding Chorus
Straight Outta Oz
[ 2016 ] Gareth
[ 2016 ] Gareth
TV Shows
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Paul
Paul
Quantico
Will Olsen
Will Olsen
SCRAPPY New York City
[ 2024 ] Alfie
[ 2024 ] Alfie
Awards and Nominations
Drama Desk Awards - 2020 - Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical
Jay Armstrong Johnson, Scotland, PA
winner
Outer Critics Circle Awards - 2020 - Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical
Jay Armstrong Johnson, Scotland, PA
- 2014 - Theatre Finalists
Jay Armstrong Johnson
Videos
Video: Jay Armstrong Johnson’s I PUT A SPELL ON YOU Releases 'Like Winnie' Music Video
by Chloe Rabinowitz - 2026-09-14 13:52:45
Video: Watch HEATED RIVALRY, HEATHERS & More at Broadway in Bryant Park Week 4
by Nicole Rosky - 2026-08-16 10:51:42
Video: HEATED RIVALRY Parody Cast Opens Up About Joining the Show
by Luka Vonier - 2026-05-27 14:30:20
Watch: Jay Armstrong Johnson and I PUT A SPELL ON YOU Team Release 'Abracadabra' Music Video
by Chloe Rabinowitz - 2025-10-03 11:32:27
Video: Watch Heath Saunders Become 'Jack Skellington' for I PUT A SPELL ON YOU
by Chloe Rabinowitz - 2024-10-14 16:39:42
Video: Jay Armstrong Johnson Performs 'De-Lovely' And More From ANYTHING GOES at The Muny
by A.A. Cristi - 2024-08-21 20:03:04
Video: Jeanna de Waal Sings 'I Get a Kick Out of You' from ANYTHING GOES at The Muny
by Joshua Wright - 2024-08-15 12:52:39
Video: Watch Jessica Vosk, Jay Armstrong Johnson, and More Perform at BROADWAY BARES: PLEASURE PARK
by Blair Ingenthron - 2023-06-25 15:03:53
Video: Mykal Kilgore Performs the BROADWAY BARES: PLEASURE PARK Finale in Rehearsal
by Blair Ingenthron - 2023-06-18 10:39:56
News
Exclusive: Go Backstage at HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Michael Major - Oct 2, 2026
Go backstage at Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, with Jay Armstrong Johnson, Troy Iwata, Ryann Redmond, and more. See exclusive photos from backstage at The Culture Club.
by Michael Major - Oct 2, 2026
Go backstage at Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, with Jay Armstrong Johnson, Troy Iwata, Ryann Redmond, and more. See exclusive photos from backstage at The Culture Club.
AT THIS PERFORMANCE… to Celebrate 23rd Anniversary at Green Room 42
by Stephi Wild - Oct 2, 2026
The monthly cabaret series spotlighting Broadway and Off-Broadway standbys, understudies, and alternates will feature performers from TITANIQUE, SIX THE MUSICAL, HEATHERS THE MUSICAL, and other productions.
by Stephi Wild - Oct 2, 2026
The monthly cabaret series spotlighting Broadway and Off-Broadway standbys, understudies, and alternates will feature performers from TITANIQUE, SIX THE MUSICAL, HEATHERS THE MUSICAL, and other productions.
Wake Up With BroadwayWorld October 1, 2026- Matthew Morrison Returns to JUST IN TIME and More
by - Oct 1, 2026
Rise and shine, BroadwayWorld! It is October 1, 2026 and it's time to catch up on all of the theatrical happenings you may have missed in the last 24 hours.
by - Oct 1, 2026
Rise and shine, BroadwayWorld! It is October 1, 2026 and it's time to catch up on all of the theatrical happenings you may have missed in the last 24 hours.
Bowen Yang to Join I PUT A SPELL ON YOU: A SANDERSON SISTER ACT
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 30, 2026
Oh, Mary! star and five-time Emmy Award nominee Bowen Yang will appear in Jay Armstrong Johnson's I Put A Spell On You: A Sanderson Sister Act returning to Manhattan's Webster Hall.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 30, 2026
Oh, Mary! star and five-time Emmy Award nominee Bowen Yang will appear in Jay Armstrong Johnson's I Put A Spell On You: A Sanderson Sister Act returning to Manhattan's Webster Hall.
Wake Up With BroadwayWorld September 21, 2026- Jennifer Simard Joins SCHMIGADOON! and More
by - Sep 21, 2026
Rise and shine, BroadwayWorld! It is September 21, 2026 and it's time to catch up on all of the theatrical happenings you may have missed over the weekend.
by - Sep 21, 2026
Rise and shine, BroadwayWorld! It is September 21, 2026 and it's time to catch up on all of the theatrical happenings you may have missed over the weekend.
Listen: HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY Releases Cast Album
by Stephi Wild - Sep 18, 2026
The original cast album from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody is now available on streaming and download platforms, featuring Jay Armstrong Johnson and Jimin Moon. Listen here!
by Stephi Wild - Sep 18, 2026
The original cast album from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody is now available on streaming and download platforms, featuring Jay Armstrong Johnson and Jimin Moon. Listen here!
Exclusive Listen: 'You're a Gay Guy' From HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 17, 2026
BroadwayWorld has your exclusive first listen to the track 'You're a Gay Guy' from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody's original cast album.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 17, 2026
BroadwayWorld has your exclusive first listen to the track 'You're a Gay Guy' from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody's original cast album.
Photos: Troy Iwata and More Join HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by A.A. Cristi - Sep 14, 2026
See new production photos of Troy Iwata as Shane Hollander and Shelby Acosta in Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, now extended Off-Broadway through January 17, 2027.
by A.A. Cristi - Sep 14, 2026
See new production photos of Troy Iwata as Shane Hollander and Shelby Acosta in Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, now extended Off-Broadway through January 17, 2027.
Video: Jay Armstrong Johnson’s I PUT A SPELL ON YOU Releases 'Like Winnie' Music Video
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 14, 2026
You can now get a first look at the music video for the eleventh anniversary celebration of I Put a Spell on You, a fundraiser for the Ali Forney Center.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Sep 14, 2026
You can now get a first look at the music video for the eleventh anniversary celebration of I Put a Spell on You, a fundraiser for the Ali Forney Center.
HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY Recoups Investment and Extends a Third Time
by Stephi Wild - Sep 10, 2026
Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody recouped its half-million-dollar budget in 13 weeks and extended its run at The Culture Club due to strong audience demand.
by Stephi Wild - Sep 10, 2026
Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody recouped its half-million-dollar budget in 13 weeks and extended its run at The Culture Club due to strong audience demand.
Video: HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY Drops Second Single 'I Can Host'
by A.A. Cristi - Sep 4, 2026
Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody has released its second single, 'I Can Host,' performed by Jimin Moon, along with a new music video from the recording studio. The full Off-Broadway cast album arrives September 18.
by A.A. Cristi - Sep 4, 2026
Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody has released its second single, 'I Can Host,' performed by Jimin Moon, along with a new music video from the recording studio. The full Off-Broadway cast album arrives September 18.
Ryan Duncan Shares Backstage Secrets From HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Stephi Wild - Sep 9, 2026
In this edition of Words From The Wings, we catch up with Ryan Duncan from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, who took us backstage at The Culture Club to share some of his favorite backstage moments, must-haves, and more!
by Stephi Wild - Sep 9, 2026
In this edition of Words From The Wings, we catch up with Ryan Duncan from Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody, who took us backstage at The Culture Club to share some of his favorite backstage moments, must-haves, and more!
Photo: Troy Iwata as 'Shane Hollander' in HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Stephi Wild - Aug 31, 2026
Troy Iwata is joining the company of Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody as ‘Shane Hollander.' Check out a first look photo of him in the role.
by Stephi Wild - Aug 31, 2026
Troy Iwata is joining the company of Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody as ‘Shane Hollander.' Check out a first look photo of him in the role.
Photo: HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY Celebrates 100th Performance
by Stephi Wild - Aug 31, 2026
HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY recently celebrated its 100th performance Off-Broadway at the Culture Club. Check out a photo of the cast celebrating the milestone!
by Stephi Wild - Aug 31, 2026
HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY recently celebrated its 100th performance Off-Broadway at the Culture Club. Check out a photo of the cast celebrating the milestone!
DEATH BECOMES HER, A WALK ON THE MOON, and More Set for AT THIS PERFORMANCE... at Green Room 42
by Stephi Wild - Aug 21, 2026
Stephen DeAngelis will host the 199th edition of his monthly series, featuring standbys and understudies from DEATH BECOMES HER, A WALK ON THE MOON, and MONTE CRISTO: A NEW MUSICAL.
by Stephi Wild - Aug 21, 2026
Stephen DeAngelis will host the 199th edition of his monthly series, featuring standbys and understudies from DEATH BECOMES HER, A WALK ON THE MOON, and MONTE CRISTO: A NEW MUSICAL.
Looking for New Musicals This Season? You'll Find Them Off-Broadway
by Jennifer Ashley Tepper - Aug 30, 2026
Much has been written and expressed about how few new Broadway musicals—six—hit the boards last season. The Broadway landscape is experiencing several challenges at the moment, largely tied to the American economy as a whole. In addition, the number of new musicals per season always fluctuates. In particular, the post-pandemic seasons stuffed with productions that were waiting in the docket were bound to cause a few course-correcting smaller slates in subsequent years.
by Jennifer Ashley Tepper - Aug 30, 2026
Much has been written and expressed about how few new Broadway musicals—six—hit the boards last season. The Broadway landscape is experiencing several challenges at the moment, largely tied to the American economy as a whole. In addition, the number of new musicals per season always fluctuates. In particular, the post-pandemic seasons stuffed with productions that were waiting in the docket were bound to cause a few course-correcting smaller slates in subsequent years.
Troy Iwata Will Join Cast of HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Nicole Rosky - Aug 17, 2026
Producer Alan Kliffer announced that Troy Iwata will join the company of Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody as ‘Shane Hollander’ beginning Monday, August 31. He succeeds Aaron Alcaraz who, as previously announced, will complete his run on Sunday, August 30.
by Nicole Rosky - Aug 17, 2026
Producer Alan Kliffer announced that Troy Iwata will join the company of Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody as ‘Shane Hollander’ beginning Monday, August 31. He succeeds Aaron Alcaraz who, as previously announced, will complete his run on Sunday, August 30.
Video: Watch HEATED RIVALRY, HEATHERS & More at Broadway in Bryant Park Week 4
by Nicole Rosky - Aug 16, 2026
Broadway in Bryant Park concluded its 2026 season this week, bringing performers from The Book of Mormon, The Great Gatsby, Heathers: The Musical and Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody to the Bryant Park stage. The afternoon was hosted by 106.7 LITE FM's Helen Little, with Ashley De La Rosa serving as co-host. Watch highlights in this video!
by Nicole Rosky - Aug 16, 2026
Broadway in Bryant Park concluded its 2026 season this week, bringing performers from The Book of Mormon, The Great Gatsby, Heathers: The Musical and Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody to the Bryant Park stage. The afternoon was hosted by 106.7 LITE FM's Helen Little, with Ashley De La Rosa serving as co-host. Watch highlights in this video!
Photos: Jeff Daniels Visits HEATED RIVALRY: THE UNAUTHORIZED MUSICAL PARODY
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Aug 14, 2026
Jeff Daniels stopped by Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody Off-Broadway at The Culture Club. Daniels took photos with the company backstage post-show, including with Aaron Alcaraz and more.
by Chloe Rabinowitz - Aug 14, 2026
Jeff Daniels stopped by Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody Off-Broadway at The Culture Club. Daniels took photos with the company backstage post-show, including with Aaron Alcaraz and more.
Photos: THE BOOK OF MORMON, THE GREAT GATSBY, and More Take the Stage At BROADWAY IN BRYANT PARK Week 4
by Genevieve Rafter Keddy - Aug 13, 2026
Check out photos from Week 4 of 106.7 LITE FM's Broadway in Bryant Park! Performers from The Book of Mormon, The Great Gatsby, Heathers: The Musical and Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody took the stage for the free outdoor concert.
by Genevieve Rafter Keddy - Aug 13, 2026
Check out photos from Week 4 of 106.7 LITE FM's Broadway in Bryant Park! Performers from The Book of Mormon, The Great Gatsby, Heathers: The Musical and Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Musical Parody took the stage for the free outdoor concert.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
How many Broadway shows has Jay Armstrong Johnson been in?
Jay Armstrong Johnson has appeared on Broadway in 6 shows.
How many West End shows has Jay Armstrong Johnson been in?
Jay Armstrong Johnson has not appeared in the West End.
What awards has Jay Armstrong Johnson been nominated for?
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for Scotland, PA and Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Scotland, PA.
What awards has Jay Armstrong Johnson won?
Jay Armstrong Johnson received an Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical award from the Outer Critics Circle Awards for his role in Scotland, PA.
Tickets From $58
Tickets From $80
Tickets From $67
Tickets From $59
