STAGE CREDITS
[Off-Broadway]
Off-Broadway Return Engagement, 2024
Pastor Bill O'Keefe
[West End]
2023
Phil Connors [Replacement]
[Broadway]
Broadway Revival Production, 2022
Cinderella's Prince, The Wolf [Replacement], Rapunzel's Prince [Replacement]
[Off-Broadway]
Off-Broadway Revival, 2021
Orin Scrivello D.D.S. [Replacement]
[Off-Broadway]
Manhattan Concert Productions Concert, 2020
Potiphar
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2019
The Duke of Monroth [Replacement]
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2018
Edward Lewis
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2017
Phil Connors
[West End]
World Premiere Production, 2016
Phil Connors
[New York]
New York City Center Gala Concert, 2015
Frank Butler
[Broadway]
Roundabout Theatre Broadway Revival, 2015
Bruce Granit
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2014
Rocky Balboa
[Off-Broadway]
2012
Performer
[Broadway]
Roundabout Theatre Company Production, 2012
Neville Landless
[New York]
Workshop, 2011
Rocky
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2009
Performer
[Los Angeles]
World Premiere, 2008
Performer
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2007
Ensemble, Dewey, Grandmaster Chad, Kyle, Emmett Forrest (Understudy), Professor Callahan (Understudy)
[Philadelphia, PA (Regional)]
Prince Music Theatre Revival, 2006
Tad
[Off-Off-Broadway]
Original Off-Off-Broadway Production, 2006
Performer
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2005
Tommy DeVito [Replacement]
[Off-Broadway]
Original Off-Broadway Production, 2005
Adam, Adam
[Broadway]
Actors’ Fund Concert, 2005
'Life is Like a Train'' Porter, Performer
[Off-Broadway]
Original Off-Broadway Production, 2005
Luke, Luke
[US Tour]
World Premiere, 2004
Ensemble
[New York]
World Premiere, 2004
Performer
[Broadway]
Original Broadway Production, 2003
Fiyero [Replacement]
[Milburn, NJ (Regional)]
Paper Mill Production, 2003
Danny Zuko
[Milburn, NJ (Regional)]
Paper Mill Production, 2003
Dino
[Off-Broadway]
Off-Broadway Production, 2000
Messrs Vlastnik/Washington/Thorell/Zola (Understudy)
[Broadway]
Broadway Production, 1999
Joey [Replacement]
Movies
Joyful Noise
[ 2012 ] Caleb
And So It Goes
[ 2014 ] Ted
Here After
[ 2020 ] Michael
Jersey Boys Live!
[ 2022 ] Tommy Devito
Atrabilious
[ 2023 ] Greg Meyers
TV Shows
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Mike Dodds
A Tippling Adventure
The Missus Downstairs
[ 2022-2024 ] Dr. Smith
Son of a Critch
Ted Turpin
The Equalizer
[ 2021-2025 ] Charles Winston
Awards and Nominations

winner
Drama Desk Awards - 2017 - Outstanding Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, Groundhog Day
Drama League Awards - 2017 - Distinguished Performance Award
Andy Karl, Groundhog Day

winner
Olivier Awards - 2017 - Best Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, Groundhog Day

winner
Outer Critics Circle Awards - 2017 - Outstanding Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, Groundhog Day
Tony Awards - 2017 - Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
Andy Karl, Groundhog Day The Musical
Drama Desk Awards - 2015 - Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, On the Twentieth Century
Drama League Awards - 2015 - Distinguished Performance Award
Andy Karl, On the Twentieth Century

winner
Outer Critics Circle Awards - 2015 - Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, On the Twentieth Century
Tony Awards - 2015 - Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical
Andy Karl, On the Twentieth Century
Drama Desk Awards - 2014 - Outstanding Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, Rocky
Drama League Awards - 2014 - Distinguished Performance Award
Andy Karl, Rocky
Outer Critics Circle Awards - 2014 - Outstanding Actor in a Musical
Andy Karl, Rocky
Tony Awards - 2014 - Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
Andy Karl, Rocky
Drama Desk Awards - 2013 - Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical
Andy Karl, The Mystery of Edwin Drood
News
Andy Karl Will Lead BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL in Perth
by Stephi Wild - May 21, 2026
Broadway star Andy Karl will lead the Perth season of BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL at Crown Theatre, with Jenni Little joining as Barbara Maitland while Elise McCann takes parental leave. Several cast members reprise their roles from Melbourne.
BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL To Play Festival Theatre
by Marissa Faith Curley - May 3, 2026
Michael Cassel Group, Warner Bros. Theatre Ventures and Langley Park Productions has announced that BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL will play Adelaide in October. BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL features music and lyrics by Australia’s own Eddie Perfect.
Video: First Look At BURNOUT PARADISE Off-Broadway
by A.A. Cristi - Mar 6, 2026
The new Off-Broadway production BURNOUT PARADISE officially opened Thursday, March 5 at the Astor Place Theatre. Watch highlights from the show in a newly released video!
Photos: BURNOUT PARADISE Celebrates Opening Night
by Jennifer Broski - Mar 6, 2026
Five performers. Four treadmills. One chance to beat the clock. Burnout Paradise, the theatrical phenomenon from award-winning Australian collective Pony Cam, is now playing Off-Broadway. Check out photos from opening night here!
BEETLEJUICE THE MUSICAL to Play Perth in 2026
by Gillian Blum - Feb 1, 2026
Michael Cassel Group, Warner Bros. Theatre Ventures and Langley Park Productions announced that the eight-time Tony Award-nominated hit musical Beetlejuice The Musical will play in Perth in 2026.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
How many Broadway shows has Andy Karl been in?
Andy Karl has appeared on Broadway in 13 shows.
How many West End shows has Andy Karl been in?
Andy Karl has appeared on London's West End in 2 shows.
What was Andy Karl's first West End show?
Andy Karl's first West End show was Groundhog Day which opened in 2016
What awards has Andy Karl been nominated for?
Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for Groundhog Day,
Distinguished Performance Award (Drama League Awards) for Groundhog Day,
Best Actor in a Musical (Olivier Awards) for Groundhog Day,
Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Groundhog Day,
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Tony Awards) for Groundhog Day The Musical,
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for On the Twentieth Century,
Distinguished Performance Award (Drama League Awards) for On the Twentieth Century,
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for On the Twentieth Century,
Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (Tony Awards) for On the Twentieth Century,
Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for Rocky,
Distinguished Performance Award (Drama League Awards) for Rocky,
Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Rocky,
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Tony Awards) for Rocky
and Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for The Mystery of Edwin Drood.
What awards has Andy Karl won?
Andy Karl has won the following awards: Outstanding Actor in a Musical at the Drama Desk Awards for Groundhog Day; Best Actor in a Musical at the Olivier Awards for Groundhog Day; and Outstanding Actor in a Musical at the Outer Critics Circle Awards for Groundhog Day. Additionally, he received the Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical at the Outer Critics Circle Awards for On the Twentieth Century.