News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Valentine's Day is here and love is all around us. At this most romantic time of the year, we can't help but wonder... what is the greatest Broadway love song ever? BroadwayWorld continues our great tradition of finding that consensus- and this year we have more answers than ever! We've gathered responses from over 1500 performers, composers, industry professionals, and entertainment personalities from all over the world. 

This year's list is presented by The Notebook, now in previews on Broadway. Based on the best selling novel that inspired the iconic film, this new musical follows Allie and Noah, both from different worlds, as they share a lifetime of love despite the forces that threaten to pull them apart, in a deeply moving portrait of the enduring power of love.

Category:
Photo
Performer
Cirque du Soleil Paramour
My favorite love song on Broadway is "Satisfied" from Hamilton. The song immediately made my heart weep. The setting takes place at Hamilton and Eliza's wedding reception. In the middle of Angelica's toast, she begins to reminisce on her secret love and feelings for Hamilton. She wanted Hamilton from the moment she laid eyes on him BUT she saw Eliza loved him as well. Her love for her younger sister is so strong that she lets her have Hamilton. Angelica's main focus is to protect her sisters, even if it means she can never be with the love of her life. Satisfied is beautiful. Renee Goldberry's voice mixed with the music is almost haunting. Her rap game is also on point! I don't know how anyone could listen to these lyrics without getting chills!
Photo
Performer
The Miracle Worker | The Lieutenant of Inishmore | Mauritus
"Your Eyes" from RENT. That's a good one.
Photo
Performer
Superhero | A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder | Ghost
"You Matter to Me" from Waitress because Gavin Creel and Sara Bareilles are singing it right now and I'm going to go see it as soon as I can.
Photo
Performer
Law & Order
It would have to be "Light My Candle" from Rent. You know, it's dark and it's seedy and it just happens, it seems, almost in an improvisational way. Two people meeting. One looking for a packet and the other one who's put up barriers to the world. And so, to me, that's probably, for my taste, the closest thing to a love song that I respond to.
Photo
Performer
Mamma Mia!
“On The Streets of Dublin” from A Man of No Importance. This song is sheer perfection musically and lyrically. It is the ultimate “love of life” song: an impassioned cry to open your eyes and love what is there at your fingertips, in your veins, and in your blood.
Photo
Performer
A Bronx Tale: The Musical
My favorite Broadway love song is: “Forever Yours” from Once On This Island. The song manages to capture so much beauty and heartbreak in every other phrase. The juxtaposition is so magnificent.
Photo
Performer
South Pacific | International Opera Star
After much contemplation, I keep coming back to one of the first legit songs I ever learned after my voice changed from boy soprano to baritone - "Some Enchanted Evening" from SOUTH PACIFIC. After having performed this song out of the context of the Rodgers and Hammerstein musical, and now having performed it over 200 times with LCT and LCT Nat'l Tour, it still evokes great emotion and love in me every time I sing it. It remains for me one of the best loved love songs ever written, for any generation - it is timeless....I've gotta go get ready to enchant now.
Photo
Performer
The Front Page | Is He Dead? | Lovemusik
One of my favorite Broadway love songs is "I Don't Know His Name" from She Loves Me. It's all about meeting someone and them revealing their inside as opposed to just judging them from the outside, because they meet through the letters. That's a really pretty one.
Photo
Performer
Romeo and Juliet | The Mystery of Edwin Drood
I'll tell you what, I love "Follow Your Heart" from Urinetown. I just love that duet and that moment and that show. It's fantastic.
Photo
Performer
Present Laughter | Cry Baby | The Pajama Game | Fiddler on the Roof | 1776
"Maria" from WEST SIDE STORY. Powerful young love propelling the melody and he can't stop saying her name. "Not a Day Goes By" - talk about having your heart on your sleeve! and..."Sometimes a Day Goes By" concise, with heartbreaking irony.
Photo
Performer
The Band's Visit | Under My Skin
Well, it sounds obvious, but my favorite right now is the love song I get to sing in The Band’s Visit, “The Beat of Your Heart." Among the many things he achieves with “The Beat of Your Heart," David Yazbek ingeniously turns a song about lost love into a song of inspiration to all those lovers who have lost their way. Every night I feel grateful to be able to sing “Maybe music is the food of love, but music and love, who can tell them apart?” I mean, music and love. What else is there, right?
Photo
Performer
Oklahoma!
“If I Loved You” is one of the greatest love songs of all time, so I guess that’s mine!
Photo
Performer
Jitney | The Book of Mormon | Grey Gardens
"The Next Ten Minutes" from The Last Five Years.
Photo
Performer
The Lion King | The 39 Steps
"Not While I’m Around" from Sweeney Todd. Love it because I think it’s melodically & lyrically perfect and is both sweet & haunting at the same time.
Photo
Performer
A View From the Bridge | Oliver! Annie Get Your Gun | Hart to Hart | The Vagina Monologues
Although my reasons are personal, my favorite song is "He Was Too Good To Me" by Rodgers and Hart.
Photo
Performer
Doubt (Film)
I love "What More Can I Say" from FALSETTOS. It's gay and contemporary and beautiful; but it's also universal, so a woman could sing it too. I love Michael Rupert singing it from the original cast, and Tami Tappan's version on her album is equally gorgeous.
Photo
Performer
Saturday Night Fever | Smokey Joe's Cafe | Beauty and the Beast
My choice is "This Nearly Was Mine." It's a song about loss, yes, but If you can find the version by Ed Alstrom (on "Acid Cabaret") I promise it will tear your heart out. The song aches with a missed opportunity, but you know that the singer is a changed person and will not let that chance pass again, which is ultimately most hopeful and romantic!
Photo
Performer
The Present
I think it would have to be "Everyone Loves Louis" from Sunday in the Park with George. Not your usual romantic love song but a complicated funny plea, in a way. Dot sings of Louis the Baker, to George the Artist, who she truly loves but can't truly have. That excruciating pain of love. I sing it as my warm up song most nights when performing.
Photo
Performer
New York New York
My favorite love song from a musical is probably It "Couldn’t Please Me More" from Cabaret. It’s written by one of the most indelible and nuanced composer/lyricist duos of all-time in Kander and Ebb. The song is beautiful, unique, and expresses the unavoidable connections between love and death, hope and loss. The song, like much of Cabaret, shows us the importance of a dim light when in complete darkness. And what better way is there to express love than by gifting a pineapple.
Photo
Performer
The Cher Show | Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
"On the Street Where You Live" from MY FAIR LADY is my favorite Broadway love song. I think it's so poetic, dreamy, and romantic. Plus, my husband, Jonathan Shew, sent me a recording of him singing it when we were first dating and he sounded incredible :) I smile every time I listen to it!
Photo
Performer
Superhero
"My Man" from Funny Girl because I love Barbra Streisand and it's heartbreaking and hopeful and beautiful and I love Funny Girl, everything about Funny Girl.
Photo
Performer
The Phantom of the Opera
"They Were You" from The Fantasticks. Simple melody, simple lyrics, profound effect. It gets me every time. I can't stop there, though! "I've Grown Accustomed to Her Face" from My Fair Lady is another one. Simple, specific and incredibly powerful.
Photo
Performer
Flashdance | Catch Me if You Can
“Only You” from Starlight Express.
Photo
Performer
Dreamgirls | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Wicked
My favorite Broadway love song is "I Got Love" from a musical back in the day called Purlie
Photo
Performer
House Plant
“I Am Changing” Dream Girls. I love it for many reasons but this particular line “All of my life I’ve been a fool / Who said I could do it all alone.” THAT for me is love.
Photo
Performer
One Day
I am crazy for "A Little Bit in Love" from Wonderful Town. This song is the perfect combination of classic broadway romance with a modern train of thought. The first lyric is a simple sigh of relief, it's so dreamy!
Photo
Performer
Ghost The Musical
"Trust" in Me by Etta James.
Photo
Performer
Linda | Fish in the Dark | Bad Jews | Carrie
There really are too many to choose just one! Three of my favorites are "They Were You" from the Fantasticks, "Do You Love Me?" from Fiddler and "Fable" from Light in the Piazza. All extremely different but equally beautiful and moving songs about love. Also, when Tony and Maria first meet in West Side Story-- one of the most romantic scenes in theater ever.
Photo
Performer
Mean Girls
I love Valentine’s Day, but I love Andrew Lippa more. Every song from Big Fish seems to track with falling or being in love, but especially “Time Stops.” If/when this is revived, please let me be 30, still southern and unemployed.
Photo
Performer
Next Fall
My favorite song for Valentine's Day is "Something Wonderful" from THE KING AND I. I like it because it exactly describes my feelings about my husband Larry.

Videos


TICKET CENTRAL

Recommended For You