Shows at the Niblo's Garden |
| DATES |
PRODUCTION |
| 11/5/1894 | - | | A Tale of Corsica (1894) |
| 10/1/1894 | - | | Pawn Ticket (1894) |
| 9/17/1894 | - | | Tide of Life (1894) |
| 8/20/1894 | - | | The Life Guard (1894) |
| 8/11/1894 | - | | In the Name of the Czar (1894) |
| 12/30/1890 | - | 12/30/1890 | Babes in the Wood (1890) |
| 10/20/1890 | - | | Nero (1890) |
| 9/30/1889 | - | 10/5/1889 | The Pearl of Pekin (1889) |
| 5/12/1879 | - | 5/12/1879 | Mosquito (1870) |
| 3/5/1879 | - | 3/5/1879 | The Black Crook (1879) |
| 1/22/1877 | - | 1/22/1877 | Around the World in 80 Days (1877) |
| 12/25/1876 | - | 12/25/1876 | Azurine (1876) |
| 9/18/1876 | - | 9/18/1876 | Baba! (1876) |
| 2/1/1875 | - | 2/1/1875 | Tom and Jerry (1875) |
| 12/21/1874 | - | 12/21/1874 | Jack and Jill (1874) |
| 9/7/1874 | - | 9/7/1874 | The Deluge (1874) |
| 7/27/1874 | - | 7/27/1874 | Evangeline (1874) |
| 12/8/1873 | - | 12/8/1873 | The Children in the Wood (1873) |
| 9/10/1873 | - | 9/10/1873 | The Belles of the Kitchen (1873) |
| 8/18/1873 | - | 8/18/1873 | The Black Crook (1873) |
| 4/28/1873 | - | 4/28/1873 | Azrael (1873) |
| 4/21/1873 | - | 4/21/1873 | The Wrong Man in the Right Place (1873) |
| 4/14/1873 | - | 4/14/1873 | The Belles of the Kitchen (1873) |
| 11/30/1872 | - | 11/30/1872 | Leo and Lotos (1872) |
| 4/1/1872 | - | 4/1/1872 | Poll and Partner Joe (1872) |
| 4/1/1872 | - | 4/20/1872 | Poll and Partner Joe (1872) |
| 3/4/1872 | - | 3/4/1872 | La Belle Sauvage (1872) |
| 3/4/1872 | - | 3/30/1872 | La Belle Sauvage (1872) |
| 2/26/1872 | - | 2/26/1872 | The Naiad Queen (1872) |
| 2/26/1872 | - | 3/2/1872 | The Naiad Queen (1872) |
| 12/18/1871 | - | 12/18/1871 | The Black Crook (1871) |
| 12/18/1871 | - | 2/24/1872 | The Black Crook (1871) |
| 9/18/1871 | - | 9/18/1871 | Carl, the Fiddler (1871) |
| 9/18/1871 | - | 9/30/1871 | Carl, the Fiddler (1871) |
| 8/21/1871 | - | 9/30/1871 | Fritz, Our Cousin German (1871) |
| 6/12/1871 | - | 6/12/1871 | Paul Clifford (1871) |
| 6/12/1871 | - | 6/24/1871 | Paul Clifford (1871) |
| 12/12/1870 | - | 12/12/1870 | The Black Crook (1870) |
| 12/12/1870 | - | 4/8/1871 | The Black Crook (1870) |
| 11/14/1870 | - | | The Rapparee (1870) |
| 10/10/1870 | - | 10/10/1870 | Little Nell and the Marchioness (1870) |
| 10/10/1870 | - | 10/20/1870 | Little Nell and the Marchioness (1870) |
| 9/12/1870 | - | | Heartsease (1870) |
| 8/29/1870 | - | | True as Steel (1870) |
| 8/22/1870 | - | | Under the Palm (1870) |
| 6/6/1870 | - | | Not Guilty (1870) |
| 5/23/1870 | - | 5/23/1870 | The Forty Thieves (1870) |
| 5/23/1870 | - | 6/4/1870 | The Forty Thieves (1870) |
| 5/12/1870 | - | 5/12/1870 | La Sonnambula (1870) |
| 4/4/1870 | - | 4/4/1870 | Pippin (1870) |
| 4/4/1870 | - | 4/30/1870 | Pippin (1870) |
| 3/28/1870 | - | | The Emerald Ring (1870) |
| 2/21/1870 | - | | Innisfallen (1870) |
| 12/6/1869 | - | 12/18/1869 | The Little Detective (1869) |
| 12/6/1869 | - | 12/18/1869 | An Object of Interest (1869) |
| 12/6/1869 | - | | The Little Detective (1869) |
| 11/22/1869 | - | 12/4/1869 | The Firefly (1869) |
| 11/22/1869 | - | 12/4/1869 | The Firefly (1869) |
| 11/1/1869 | - | | Little Nell and the Marchioness (1869) |
| 10/25/1869 | - | | Oliver Twist (1869) |
| 10/18/1869 | - | | East Lynne (1869) |
| 9/6/1869 | - | | Formosa: ("The Most Beautiful") (1869) |
| 8/2/1869 | - | 9/4/1869 | Arrah-Na-Pogue (1869) |
| 8/2/1869 | - | 9/4/1869 | Arrah-Na-Pogue (1869) |
| 5/29/1869 | - | 5/29/1869 | Sinbad the Sailor (1869) |
| 5/29/1869 | - | 7/31/1869 | Sindbad the Sailor, or, the Ungenial Geni and the Little Cabin Boy!! (1869) |
| 5/29/1869 | - | 7/31/1869 | Sinbad the Sailor (1869) |
| 2/1/1869 | - | 5/28/1869 | The Forty Thieves (1869) |
| 2/1/1869 | - | 5/28/1869 | The Forty Thieves (1869) |
| 11/16/1868 | - | | After Dark (1868) |
| 7/13/1868 | - | 10/8/1868 | Barbe-Bleue (1868) |
| 7/13/1868 | - | 10/8/1868 | Barbe-Bleue (1868) |
| 1/17/1868 | - | 7/11/1868 | The White Fawn (1868) |
| 1/17/1868 | - | 7/11/1868 | The White Fawn (1868) |
| 9/15/1866 | - | 1/4/1868 | The Black Crook (1866) |
| 9/12/1866 | - | 1/4/1868 | The Black Crook (1866) |
| 11/15/1865 | - | 11/15/1865 | Arrah-Na-Pogue (1865) |
| 7/12/1865 | - | 9/16/1865 | Arrah-Na-Pogue (1865) |
| 7/12/1865 | - | | Arrah-Na-Pogue (1865) |
| 6/1/1864 | - | 6/4/1864 | Miss Lotta (1864) |
| 3/28/1864 | - | | The Fool's Revenge (1864) |
| 2/25/1864 | - | 4/30/1864 | Ba-Ta-Clan (1864) |
| 2/11/1864 | - | 4/30/1864 | Le Violoneux (1864) |
| 2/6/1864 | - | 4/30/1864 | Le Mariage Aux Lanternes (1864) |
| 2/5/1864 | - | 2/1/1864 | Maritana (1864) |
| 1/13/1864 | - | 2/1/1864 | The Bohemian Girl (1864) |
| 1/12/1864 | - | 4/30/1864 | Trombalcazar (1864) |
| 1/9/1864 | - | 4/30/1864 | Les Deux Aveugles (1864) |
| 3/16/1863 | - | 3/16/1863 | The Enchantress (1863) |
| 3/16/1863 | - | 3/28/1863 | The Enchantress (1863) |
| 2/23/1863 | - | 3/14/1863 | Satanella (1863) |
| 2/23/1863 | - | 3/14/1863 | Satanella (1863) |
| 2/14/1863 | - | 2/14/1863 | La Rose de Saint-Flour (1863) |
| 6/9/1862 | - | 6/21/1862 | The Syren (1862) |
| 6/9/1862 | - | 6/21/1862 | The Syren (1862) |
| 4/14/1862 | - | 6/7/1862 | The Enchantress! (1862) |
| 4/4/1862 | - | 6/7/1862 | The Enchantress! (1862) |
| 5/7/1860 | - | 5/19/1860 | Blue Beard (1860) |
| 5/7/1860 | - | 5/19/1860 | Blue Beard (1860) |
| 6/9/1859 | - | 6/10/1859 | The Beggar's Opera (1859) |
| 6/9/1859 | - | 6/21/1859 | Rob Roy (1859) |
| 6/8/1859 | - | 6/10/1859 | The Beggar's Opera (1859) |
| 6/6/1859 | - | 6/11/1859 | The Bohemian Girl (1859) |
| 6/6/1859 | - | 6/11/1859 | The Bohemian Girl (1859) |
| 6/1/1859 | - | 6/2/1859 | The Waterman (1859) |
| 6/1/1859 | - | 6/2/1859 | The Waterman (1859) |
| 5/9/1859 | - | 6/3/1859 | Rob Roy (1859) |
| 7/13/1858 | - | | Columbus el Filibustero!! (1857) |
| 9/27/1855 | - | 10/23/1855 | Rip Van Winkle (1855) |
| 9/27/1855 | - | 10/23/1855 | Rip Van Winkle (1855) |
| 9/14/1855 | - | 11/2/1855 | The Beggar's Opera (1855) |
| 9/14/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | The Beggar's Opera (1855) |
| 7/2/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | A Queen of a Day (1855) |
| 6/18/1855 | - | 6/28/1855 | The Daughter of St. Mark (1855) |
| 6/18/1855 | - | 6/28/1855 | The Daughter of St. Mark (1855) |
| 6/2/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | The Bohemian Girl (1855) |
| 6/2/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | The Bohemian Girl (1855) |
| 6/2/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | A Queen of a Day (1855) |
| 5/25/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | Maritana (1855) |
| 5/25/1855 | - | 11/3/1855 | Maritana (1855) |
| 4/9/1855 | - | 4/9/1855 | The Marriage of Georgette (1855) |
| 4/9/1855 | - | 4/9/1855 | The Marriage of Georgette (1855) |
| 7/4/1854 | - | 7/4/1854 | The Enchantress (1854) |
| 6/4/1854 | - | 8/5/1854 | The Enchantress (1854) |
| 7/20/1853 | - | 8/16/1853 | The Bohemian Girl (1853) |
| 6/20/1853 | - | 8/16/1853 | The Bohemian Girl (1853) |
| 12/17/1852 | - | 12/23/1852 | The Basket Maker's Wife (1852) |
| 12/17/1852 | - | 12/23/1852 | The Basket Maker's Wife (1852) |
| 5/31/1852 | - | 6/4/1852 | The Enchantress (1852) |
| 5/31/1852 | - | 6/4/1852 | The Enchantress (1852) |
| - | | The Duke's Motto () |
