A small Pennsylvania town is shaken when Zack Fisher, the infant son of a prominent Amish family, is kidnapped. Accusations fly. Although everyone comes under suspicion, the case goes cold. Zack’s sister Naomi, who was supposed to be watching him, blames herself for the next 20 years – then takes matters into her own hands. Packed with a cast of interesting and complex characters, including a quirky, noir-style detective and an amateur Amish sleuth, this musical mystery tells a moving story about learning to forgive yourself.
Presented in partnership with Blue Gate Musicals, with a script by Martha Bolton based on Wanda Brunstetter’s best-selling Daughters of Lancaster County series, this light-hearted whodunit is brought to life by a talented cast of professionals. Chosen from 5,000 hopefuls at auditions across the country, our cast members have appeared at Sight & Sound Theatres, Ozark Actors Theatre, Peach State Summer Theatre, Lexington Children’s Theatre, South Bend Civic Theatre and other venues. This production includes several veterans of the Bird-in-Hand Stage.
If faith, family and self-forgiveness matter to you, Stolen will steal your heart.
The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie's Biscuits (4/3/25-8/2/25)
The Christmas Candy Caper (10/30/25-12/27/25)
Bird-in-Hand Stage is at 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA.
The Christmas Candy Caper (11/1/24-12/28/24)
Half Stitched. . .the Musical (8/13/24-10/24/24)
The Confession (4/4/24-8/3/24)
Our Christmas Dinner (10/26/23-12/30/23)
The Home Game (8/4/23-10/19/23)
Dear Soldier Boy (4/6/23-7/27/23)
Josiah for President (8/18/22-10/21/22)
A Simple Sanctuary (4/8/22-8/10/22)
The Best of Me (7/13/21-10/20/21)
The Güt Life! Christmas (10/30/20-1/2/21)
Videos
![]() |
Linda Eder
Keswick Theatre (3/27 - 3/27) | |
![]() |
Sesame Street Live! Say Hello
Keswick Theatre (3/26 - 3/26) | |
![]() |
Bristol Riverside Theatre presents Purple Xperience
Bristol Riverside Theatre (7/16 - 7/20) | |
![]() |
The Dinner Detective Comedy Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Philadelphia (4/12 - 4/12) | |
![]() |
Keith Fields & Lady Sarah -A Brit of Magic - June 20th & 21st 2025 - 8pm
Smoke & Mirrors Theater in House of Magic (6/20 - 6/21) | |
![]() |
Franklin's Key
Pig Iron Theatre (6/3 - 6/29) | |
![]() |
Annie and the Fur Trappers
Community Arts Center (4/6 - 4/6) | |
![]() |
Javi Benitez • Supreme Sleight of Hand
Smoke & Mirrors Theater in House of Magic (4/18 - 4/19) | |
![]() |
& Juliet
Ensemble Arts [Academy Of Music] (3/25 - 4/6) | |
VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW |
Recommended For You