The Guthrie Theater today announced complete casting for Arsenic and Old Lace, Joseph Kesselring's classic comedy that kills with kindness. As previously announced, the incomparable Sally Wingert returns to the Guthrie stage for the first time since last season's Faith Healer, joining acclaimed comedienne and Broadway veteran Kristine Nielsen to play the pair of well-meaning sisters, Martha and Abby Brewster, respectively. The production, which marks the 70th anniversary of a play The New York Times called "so funny that none of us will ever forget it," will be directed by Joe Dowling and presented at the Guthrie for the first time since 1975.
Joining Wingert and Nielsen in this uproarious comedy are many familiar faces, including Michael Booth (Officer Klein), Bob Davis (Teddy Brewster), Tyson Forbes (Jonathan Brewster), Nathaniel Fuller (Reverend Dr. Harper / Mr. Witherspoon), Jonas Goslow (Mortimer Brewster), Terry Hempleman (Officer O'Hara), Hugh Kennedy (Officer Brophy), Kathryn Lawrey (Elaine Harper), Kris L. Nelson (Dr. Einstein) and Peter Thomson (Mr. Gibbs/Lieutenant Rooney).Spinster sisters Abby and Martha Brewster have taken to befriending lonely older gentlemen and then poisoning them with arsenic-laced elderberry wine - all while chatting up a minister, devoting themselves to charity and trying to keep an eye on their crazy but harmless nephew Teddy (Davis), who thinks he's Teddy Roosevelt and has been digging the Panama Canal in the Brewsters' cellar. All of this goes undetected until the sisters' theater critic nephew Mortimer (Goslow) stops by one evening and finds a body in their window seat. When the woman he wants to marry, Elaine Harper (Lawrey), arrives to accompany him to the theater, Mortimer is in such a flustered state that the pair quarrel and Elaine runs off. The real trouble, however, appears in the form of yet another nephew, Jonathan (Forbes), a criminal maniac who has had plastic surgery that makes him look like Boris Karloff. It turns out that he and his associate Dr. Einstein (Nelson) have a body of their own that they'd like to bury and are delighted to discover Teddy's "canal" in the cellar. As bodies are moved and nosy policemen deftly avoided, Mortimer must figure out how to end his aunts' deadly hobby without sending them to prison and find a way for him and Elaine to have a future together.Videos