The Watergate tapes helped bring down the presidency of Richard M. Nixon. The tapes Michael Bennett recorded of Broadway dancers telling intimate details of their lives led to the creation of A Chorus Line. But this past Monday night at Birdland, a captivated audience thrilled to the sounds of the most historically significant tape in the history of American culture. Yes, I'm writing of the mixtape a young Donna Lynne Champlin recorded and sent anonymously to the boy she was crushing on, Broadway star-to-be Brian d'Arcy James. In one of the more deliriously mad episodes of her debut cabaret show, Finishing The Hat, Champlin sings along with an excerpt from the legendary B-side of this musical love confessional, where she edited bits of different songs to give her massively-eyebrowed heartthrob clues to her identity. She then explains how she systematically stalked d'Arcy James during his Broadway runs of Blood Brothers and Carousel, before eventually being cast opposite the lad in a play reading where her character was required to seduce him.
Top: Singing "The Air Is Free"
Bottom: Demonstrating how her ex-fiancé proposed
Videos