SOUND OFF! ROOMS Rocks, RAINBOW is Resplendent

This week we are taking a listen to the new Off-Broadway rock musical ROOMS: A Rock Romance and the revival cast recording of FINIAN'S RAINBOW. From Scotland to Ireland, and back to Broadway, we, quite joyfully, jaunt...

Sitting In My Room, Nothing Is Missing

Paul Scott Goodman, along with bookwriter Miriam Gordon, has created another rock score worthy of respect and reverence with his work for the semi-autobiographical ROOMS: A Rock Romance, this coming more than ten years after his last effort, the arresting and alarmingly inventive BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY which was based on the classic 80s second-person stream-of-conciousness novel by Jay McInerney. While ROOMS lacks the dramatic weight and engaging, esoteric storytelling style of BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY, it makes up for it in the enthusiasm and energy exhibited by the excellent leads, Leslie Kritzer and Doug Kreeger. The Scottish brogue explicitly evocative of the composer/lyricist himself (and his then girlfriend, upon whom the Kritzer role is based) is brought off with adept aplomb by the leads. Kreeger and Kritzer are both positively wonderful. Track-by-track, and hit-by-hit, the score traverses musical styles as varied and various as one would come to expect from Goodman, who always keeps one foot firmly planted in world of rock. Where the other foot may fall is anyone's guess.

The album begins with two themes that are reprised repeatedly, each time with more layers of lust, love and lyricism, both on the part of the characters and the actual composer himself. "Rooms" and "Steps" are arresting recurring themes that bring to mind the elusive elegance and eeriness of "Coma Baby" from BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY, starting off the memory play in a memorable manner. As the reprises pile on, one is immediately struck by the subtle strength of Goodman in making the seemingly innocuous, such as a simple set of stairs, so interesting and involving. "Bring the Future Faster" rocks hard and Kritzer navigates the high-belting with assuredness and the result is really quite riveting. "Friday Night Dress", with its Biblical allusions, showcases the strength of the simultaneous storytelling in an entertaining and inventive fashion. By its title alone, "Scottish Jewish Princess" purports to be funnier than it turns out to actually be, but the beginning Bossa Nova beat, which creeps into a few numbers, compounded by the intricate vocal line and patter song sibilance ultimately proves successful. The rhyme of "Uncle Georgy" and "orgy" is certainly an unexpected and funny rhyme and, in the end, the song serves a similar function to "I Hate The French" in BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY. "I Love You For All Time" at first brings to mind Sting & The Police and given the 80s time-setting of the piece, it is totally appropriate to the period. As the song builds, we become increasingly floored by the fierce and furious electricity ignited by Kritzer and Kreeger's performances. It is at this point that I came to the conclusion that even if the material were weaker, the leads would raise it up a few levels through sheer will. "Let's Go To London" contains some high-belting on the order of "A New Argentina" from EVITA and Kritzer's favorable comparisons to Patti LuPone, having played LuPone herself in a tribute show off-Broadway a few seasons ago, are justly justified. "All I Want Is Everything" is Goodman's expert musical evocation of everything 80s, and it is, in the words of Wayne & Garth from WAYNE'S WORLD, excellent, totally. "Let's Leave London" left me a little bit cold and, given that it is the turning point of the story, one wishes for a bit more from the lyrics than "two punks in love", but every song can't be a knock-out, I suppose. "NYC Forever!" contains the weakest lyrics of all and it is at this point that the ground upon which this score stands starts getting shaky, but it soon gets back on track with the next half of the show. That being said, the theme for "Pour more booze" in "NYC Forever!" hasn't left my head since I first heard the album, so, if nothing else, this track is catchy, though some re-writes are in definitely in order.

"The Diabolical" represents the point at which the central relationship begins to show signs of dissolution and the depravedness and decadence of the rock stars starts to show its effects on their romance. "Little Bit of Love" is conversational, but pulsating and painfully punishing, and ultimately a pretty perfect performance of a dramatic moment that is, pardon the pun, pregnant with the dramatic and emotional themes that have amassed by this point in the drama. The counterpoint and hushed conversation that the song ends with is ravishing. "Fear of Flying", which is reminiscent of "Odeon" in BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY, is a propulsive patter song with particularly effective sound effects, though subtlety is certainly nowhere present here, whether in Kreeger‘s performance or the album's production. Nor should it be. "Happiness" is heartbreaking and brings to mind the material meant for the mother character in BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY, as well as that show's "Kindness" so memorably recorded by Sherie Rene Scott on the Sh-K-Boom concept album. "When I'm not with him I'm drowning," perfectly illustrates the female side of this relationship and exhibits Goodman's deftness with a common phrase meaning so much more in the context of the drama, particularly since the lyrics are so often focused on alcoholism and liquid allusions - and for good reason. "Clean" is my favorite track on the album and the jaunty riff upon which the melody is based is winning - "The rhythm of the alcohol, keeps kickin'," indeed. Few composers have musicalized the demons of addiction more expertly or evocatively than Goodman both here and in BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY, which is largely concerned with cocaine addiction. The reprises of "Rooms" and "Steps" are very sad and somber, totally appropriate given the subject matter. "My Choice" could have been insufferably maudlin and sentimental, but due both to the performers and the production it is not, and, in the end, actually brings to mind the best of Sondheim in its style and tender yet tenacious turn-of-phrase. "My choice. Done./ We have a son." is about as simply elegant as you can get in musical theatre. "Each minor chord, a major test" is another excellent lyric in this equally tear-filled and tender, and tough, song. "A New Song For Scotland" is as patriotic as we are led to expect given the title, and given what has just occurred in the drama leading up to it, is a breath of fresh, clean air. And so is this score, evident, of course, in the "Finale" - and everywhere else.

Time-Life also provide us with a fun, if frivolous, bonus track called "Click", and it is quite clear why it was cut, but it is, indeed, just a little bit more of a very good thing.  The recording is also so successful in large part due to the sterling work done by producer Rob Sher, whose contributions cannot be overestimated. Speaking of good, Goodman had the misfortune of premiering (and, at that point, performing in) BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY around the same time as Jonathan Larson's RENT and was subsequently overshadowed by that work and its author. Similarly, ROOMS ended up off-Broadway in the same season as NEXT TO NORMAL. With the immeasurable loss of Larson, Goodman proves with BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY and, now, ROOMS, that he is the current master of the rock musical. Then again, I am one of those who feel BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY is just as good as RENT, and now if forced to compare would prefer ROOMS to NEXT TO NORMAL - BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY is certainly more inventive and more innovative in its style, structure and the substance of the characters than RENT, while comparisons between ROOMS and NEXT TO NORMAL are less useful. ROOMS rocks and Goodman is the rock n roll king of musical theatre - on Broadway or off as he proves with this score that certainly had me, to use a discarded phrase from NEXT TO NORMAL, feeling electric.

SCORE: 8/10

Things Are Great In Glocca Mora

While the Broadway revival of FINIAN'S RAINBOW may not have had the luck of a four-leaf clover, the masterfully produced and performed cast album is the true gold pot at the end of the titular rainbow. Forget Fred Astaire, Petula Clark, or any of their Broadway counterparts - this is the recording of FINIAN'S for the ages. It is rare that a show that produced quite so many standards as this one - I can count four off-hand - and it is to the credit of Burton Lane and E.Y. Harburg that this score shines so brightly more than fifty years following its Broadway premiere. While it may not be the most complex or innovative score of that decade, or even that year, one would be hard pressed to find a more lovely way to spend an hour in Ireland without leaving the comforts of home. Even the album art and production photos, beautifully showcased in the elegant album design, makes my heart flutter a bit. This is classic Broadway at its best.

Starting with a sparkling "Overture," and the hanky-panky of the harmonica beginning the first vocal track, this cast recording does just about everything just right. The syncopation and sibilance of every single syllable surround us as "This Time of the Year" gets going, and it is rare to hear a chorus this well-mixed and marvelous, whether on a cast album or in the theatre itself. Kate Baldwin is an instant-win with her establishing number, one of the most famous and well-worn songs in all of musical theatre, "How Are Things In Glocca Morra?" Following up that gem is the nearly equally famous and well-known "Look To The Rainbow" and the results are winsome and winning. We are treated to a complete recording of the dance break, as well, and the overall comprehensiveness of this recording is one of many myriad reasons why this album is so momentous and instantly memorable. Cheyenne Jackson, currently on NBC'S 30 ROCK but having established himself as one of the foremost male performers of the 21st century musical theatre, is immediately likeable with the most famous song in a score full of fabulous, famous standards, "Old Devil Moon". The subtle phrasing and slight homage to a 1940s Broadway delivery were certainly not lost on this attentive listener. The chemistry between Jackson and Baldwin is tangible, even on record, and one hopes to see them pair-up again in the near future, hopefully on a duets album like Jackson's current collaboration with standards master Michael Feinstein, THE POWER OF TWO. "Something Sort of Grandish" is one of the best examples of Harburg's wicked and wonderful way with words, and the reprise is equally winning and even more riotously hilarious. In "If This Isn't Love" Jackson pays homage to the vocal inflections of John Raitt and the results are resplendent, with the chorus members providing expert assistance, both comically and vocally. Even the kiss sound effect is perfect.

Character accents are one of the most treacherous treks actors must traverse, as previously alluded to above in the discussion of ROOMS, and it is to the credit of the cast of FINIAN'S RAINBOW that they pull off the Irish brogue so well, rarely over-doing it as is so commonplace in community theatre productions of the show. "Introduction To Necessity" is another fine example of the expert mixing and mastering of the choral work on this album, and though there is a slight echo here and elsewhere it seems as if that is entirely intentional and meant to bring to mind the classic Godard Lieberson-produced albums of the Golden Age. "Necessity" seems slightly old-fashioned and quaint when compared to blues songs and scatting in the scores of today, but given the time-frame in which the show was written it shows how boundary-pushing Lane was trying to be with this score. Lane, by way of this wonderful revival cast, ends the act on a rollicking and raucous note with "That Great ‘Come-and-Get-It' Day". But these marvelous moments are merely half the hues of this remarkable RAINBOW.

The "Entr'Acte", much like the "Overture" before it, beginning with that spine-tingling and classic "Old Devil Moon" cue, makes excellent use of the full-bodied orchestra, the mere presence of the thirty plus musicians an anomaly due to the crippling economics on Broadway today which, more often than not, renders the classic scores of yore anemic and antiseptic sounding in the cripplingly reduced orchestrations that plague far too many productions these days. It is rare to hear so much care and attention paid to every single second of a cast recording and the work by Tommy Krasker and company at PS Classics cannot be applauded enough. "When the Idle Poor Become the Idle Rich" starts Act Two off endearingly, and the delicate orchestrations of the dance sections are carried off with utmost care and precision, making it a truly multi-layered and mellifluous moment for both the superb cast and sumptuous orchestra. "Dance of the Golden Crock" is notable if only for the enticing harmonica playing and audible hoofing comically included on the track. On a less comprehensive and considered recording, dance tracks like this would undoubtedly be left by the wayside. "The Begat", the second act answer to "Necessity", is a fun, if innocuous, blues number, though the second act does seem to contain a bit of filler - but, in comparison to the irreproachable first act song stack, that was bound to be the case. The reprises of both "Old Devil Moon" and "Look To The Rainbow" are appropriate and accentuated with slight nuances by Jackson and Baldwin not evident in the full versions of the songs that came previously. Again, they are positively perfect in these roles, both separately and together, and more of their performances are always a welcome addition on this recording. "When I'm Not Near the Girl I Love" is the last of the big, famous standards in this score and it is performed well by Broadway regular Christopher Fitzgerald. The "Finale Ultimo" is the perfect ending to a perfect recording of a nearly perfect score, and leaves the listener wanting to go right back to the base of the rainbow and replay the album again and again. The attention to detail - of each shade and hue of every single, solitary color, both dramatic and musical - is what makes this RAINBOW an absolute winner. A true pot o' gold.

SCORE: 7.5/10