Rudetsky peppered Jordan with questions and quips, and the two teamed up for ''You and Me'' from ''The Book of Mormon.''
Jordan, a Theatre World Award winner, sang his signature songs from ''West Side Story,'' ''Bonnie & Clyde'' and ''Newsies.''
He also told a bushel of backstage stories, recalling when he clashed with Arthur Laurents; how he once wound up wearing women's pantyhouse, and why Harvey Weinstein was ''a prick.'' Plus, Jordan, 33, revealed his "most bizarre celebrity encounter'': Chita Rivera!
On working with Laurents on the revival of ''West Side Story'':
''He'd give notes and usually single out someone [for criticism]. It was part of his weird process. He never did it to me ... until my third-to-last show before I left for Florida. It was one of my best [performances], and I was really proud of it. And [Laurents] went: 'Where have you gone? You've already left the show. I didn't even know that was you on the stage.' Finally, I said: 'I had a great show. I don't know if you're trying to prove something.' And Laurents said, 'Oh, now, you're flexing your masculinity in front of everyone?' And I said: 'Isn't that what you're doing?' ... Later on, I kinda apologized, not for what I said, but for calling him out in front of the company.''
On filming his first on-screen, bedroom scene in ''The Last Five Years'':
''Anna [Kendrick] is under the sheets, and ... I'm on top of her. But I had my underwear on, and they were black. The director said: 'We can see your underwear.' I said: 'What do you want me to do?' So they took a women's pair of nude-colored pantyhose and cut out the legs, so I had a little pair of shorts. It didn't make a whole lot of difference. I felt like a complete idiot.''
On working with Weinstein, who produced ''Finding Neverland'':
''There was no guarantee [I'd get to do the show on Broadway], but I certainly wanted it. And I fought for it. ... It was a great company, and it was the first time I got to play an adult. ... Harvey was a prick. I felt like I was constantly being interviewed for a job I already had. After I found out I wasn't going forward with the show, he tried to pawn off another gig on me that was vastly inferior.''
On auditioning for ''Spring Awakening'':
''Originally, I went in for Melchoir. Then they decided I should go in for Moritz. They decided I was too twinkie, so I should go in for Georg. Then they decided: 'We'll make you the more masculine gay boy, Hanschen.' ... There were five or six of us for the final callback. We were doing the dances with the chairs. I got so into it. I picked up a chair and put it down [so hard] that it broke. I kicked away the pieces and kept going. Andy Mientus [who later would co-star with Jordan on NBC's ''Smash''] said: 'I was there! And the rest of us were on the sideline, thinking, ''Damn it. That guy's gonna get the role; he broke the chair!'' But I didn't get it.''
On Chita Rivera literally running into him:
''I was doing the Tonys and I was in 'Rock of Ages.' That year, all of the nominated shows were in the big opening number. And that year, Chita Rivera was doing her one-woman show ['The Dancer's Life']. So she was backstage, and I was in my '80s wig, looking like a fool. We're waiting to go on, during the rehearsal, when a bunch of male dancers came running offstage. Chita got frightened and grabbed me and said, ''Save me!'' It was like a wave of them. Those male dancers have monstrous calves, and I have little chicken legs.''
Finally, for the record, here's Jordan's complete song list from his Herbst Theatre concert:
Editor's note: After this story originally ran, Jordan posted a correction on his Twitter: ''Whoops. I dunno what I was smoking, I totally meant Liza Minnelli, not Chita Rivera. Sorry Liza! (and Chita)"
Videos