There's no way around it. While watching 3D Theatricals' largely pleasing stage production of the enduring Richard Rodgers/Oscar Hammerstein II Broadway classic THE SOUND OF MUSIC—now playing at the Plummer Auditorium in Fullerton, CA through February 26—one can't help but be reminded of just how great the more popular, Oscar®-winning movie musical version truly is compared to its parental stage roots.
Though by its own merits, the stage version of THE SOUND OF MUSIC (first produced on Broadway in 1959) is itself a triumph of song, story and theatricality, all of which contributed significantly to its later, much more beloved 1965 film adaptation. But, unfortunately, the side-effect of seeing a fully-mounted stage production of that film's original theatrical source material is the revelation of its early story flaws, character underdevelopment, and even a few ignorable songs that seemed to have been miraculously excised or fixed in its celluloid reincarnation.Under the direction of 3D Theatricals' own Artistic Director T.J. Dawson, this honorable, full-scale production of THE SOUND OF MUSIC smartly uses the familiarity of its origins within the grand, church-like environment of its venue to elevate the show above from yet another run-of-the-mill production one might catch at the local high school or even a decent-size community theater. Aside from the effectively antiquated sets and the aging but still beautiful background flats that go whizzing up and down the stage throughout the show, the production itself feels lovingly embraced by the Plummer Auditorium's vintage surfaces.
While there are a few laughably awkward moments that can be blamed partially on the original book by Howard Lindsay and Russel Crouse—coupled with a few forced performances from isolated peripheral cast members—this enjoyable stage production is at its utmost best during the well-orchestrated musical numbers, especially the show's signature tunes that feature Maria, the nuns (oh, the magnificent harmonies these ladies produce!), and, of course, the seven adorable children. From its hauntingly stirring opening hymn followed by Huber's tone-perfect delivery of the title song, to the tear-inducing showstopper sung by Marty that closes the first act, the show does a great job of honoring these scenes that have been otherwise branded into our brains for decades. Many novices to the Broadway original will be surprised by some of the differences that don't quite line-up with the movie version. Some of these instances include the moment featuring "My Favorite Things," which actually started life as a duet between Maria and Mother Abess. Later, "The Lonely Goatherd" is performed as the song Maria and the children sing during a thunderstorm, instead of serving it as a soundtrack to a puppet show.
Most notably, a couple of songs that were cut out of the film—"How Can Love Survive" and "No Way To Stop It"—remain in this production, and, boy, do they ever put a head-scratching, screeching halt to the show (their omission in the film now makes total sense). On the flip side, though, its great to see both "I Have Confidence" and "Something Good"—two songs written specifically for the film—inserted into this stage concoction, even though the latter feels much less romantic in its execution than I had hoped.
But, overall, the enjoyment of this production can be ultimately attributed to its very excellent ensemble, particularly the show's central lead. Having an eerie but welcome resemblance to the Maria in the film, Julie Andrews (especially when seen in profile), Huber truly embodies the role, especially in her impressive, wonderful singing. The same can be said of the marvelously-voiced Marty, whose every presence adds a palpable regal air to her scenes, even though the actress does feel much younger than her role may suggest.
Traversing the stage with appropriate entitlement, Van Velzer makes for a believably posh Schräder. The rather enthusiastic James Stellos, who plays family friend Max Detweiler, brings lots of humor to his scenes, though, I don't recall the character being quite so effeminate (admittedly, I've always had my suspicions). And as the Captain, Schmid does his best with his less showy role, but at times gets usurped by the stronger, more energetic females that dominate the show. Finally, the Von Trapp children, it should be noted, are all nicely cast: Tessa Grady (Liesl), Griffin Runnels (Friedrich), Jenna Lea Rosen (Louisa), Carter Thomas (Kurt), Cozi Zuehlsdorff (Brigitta), Jaidyn Young (Marta), and scene-stealing Hadley Miller (as little Gretl). Much can be discussed about the pervasive love bestowed upon THE SOUND OF MUSIC. Whether in its umpteenth showing on television, in its latest digitally-enhanced high-definition remastering, or, as in this case, in an enjoyable stage revival, the musical's reach is hard to escape. It's also hard to escape the notion that the far superior movie adaptation—which presented a higher degree of conflict and story progression—is undoubtedly an improvement from its stage origins, thanks to the work introduced by its Oscar-nominated screenwriter Ernest Lehman and it's own Oscar-winning director Robert Wise. Sure, it's an unfair comparison: flat, moving sets were tossed aside in favor of widescreen outdoor vistas. But nonetheless, seeing the musical in its stage form is still an undeniable treat, if only to experience its fantastic, nostalgic score performed live by actors and musicians. Thanks to 3D Theatricals' lovely revival, that very experience can be realized on a grand scale once again. I dare you not to smile.Videos