Yes. I have to admit that I wasn't a fan of most of what they shared of "One Day More", especially Russell Crowe's part, but it was nice to finally get a hint of how he's going to sound!
Still think it looks stunning, I was hoping the goosebumps wouldn't just be an IDAD thing. Russell Crowe sounds good, very different to Hugh, I doubt by design but it works. Nice to see some of Eddie and Aaron too.
Did not like Russel's singing, but at least he's no Gerard Butler? I'm not a fan of Amanda's either, though I think that's mostly because I really dislike operatic vibrato, which is what she seems to be going for. Other than that- can't wait! Hathaway is going to get praise heaped upon praise for this. Even Hugh is starting to win me over. Also, was it just me, or did anyone think the mixing sounded a little strange in this trailer?
Edited to add: I also think that Samantha Barks is going to be the break-out star of this movie. She may not get an Oscar nod, but this is going to make her famous outside the theater world.
Hugh/Valjean is riding on a coach presumably bound for Calais with Cosette. That was the right way to contemplate the impact of what they were doing. He could not be belting out his thoughts from the coach - that would sound a little ludicrous. LOL!
Hugh is reinterpreting the way the role has been portrayed on stage ( all those with no holds-barred singing, who cares if the acting is secondary??) -- and with directorial choices being made by Hooper.
There is a lot of dialog and a lot of talk-sing on this trailer, especially from Hugh, partly to illustrate that the acting or portrayal of character or a situation is more realistic and that the intimacy of the big screen ( rather than a stage production) is dictating this kind of close-up performance ( there will be time for the big numbers!)...
....and maybe, partly not to scare people from a completely sung-through format.
I think the trailer is meant for general audiences, not for musical theatre geeks
I also liked the way Russell was acting/singing his One Day More part -- he looked like he was briefing his troops, which is what it should be. Very firm and decisive, with military precision! On stage, Javert comes out of the blue, like a cameo, and simply belts his lines.
I'm a little easy on Crowe's singing. I always found that part of the song lyrically clunky and in context the way he is delivering it probably fits. Agree on the military precision. He might as well have a large French flag behind him.
Eddie in his small singing part was a pleasant surprise.
The whole trailer is great. I cannot wait to see the whole "Master of the House" number.
Crowe sounds like he's singing to a metronome, but in all fairness, so does the full chorus that comes in right after him. A little too robotic in the musical direction, right then.
I don't mind his (rock & roll) voice, but I hope he "loosens up" with the phrasing the way Jackman seems to have.
As for Seyfried ... I can't tell yet. I think her acting is going to carry the performance, and it looks good. Her singing voice is too thin with that slim, rapid-fire vibrato. If it doesn't get in the way of the songs, I can live with it. But she's not winning me over vocally in these clips.
I will say that the overall look, feel, and power of the story seem to be coming through beautifully. And above all else, including the score, Les Miz is a classic tale. One for the ages.
joined:5/28/05
Posted: 11/8/12 at 10:24am