Emma Thompson in the gift opening/bedroom scene is some of the most brilliant acting ever put on screen. Even though the script for this scene is poorly constructed, Emma still commits to it and makes it work.
Alan Rickman saying "yes" repeatedly to Laura Linney. Emma Thompson trying to stop crying. Hugh Grant dancing. The scene in the Milwaukee bar. When the bodyguard sings "Good King Wenceslaus" (probably my favorite single moment).
And what about the music?!?! One of the greatest film scores EVER. It's a shame the score was never commercially released on CD, but it is...out there. And it is glorious.
Emma's talent makes a poorly written scene work. An example of an excellent actor overcoming bad material.
***spoiler alert***
Emma's expecting the piece of jewelry that she saw her husband buy. She opens one present and then poof she realizes her husband bought the jewelry for another woman? Did I miss the scene where Alan Rickman tells her "This is the only present you are getting this Christmas and I have no other surprises for you, even though we have only opened one present on Christmas Eve!" The scene really should have been at the end of Christmas when we as an audience realize there's no possible way Emma's getting another present.
joined:6/12/08
Posted: 10/8/12 at 11:59am