PERFECT Casting Game

[suttonfoster]

I thought we could do a game on this thread. One person names a Broadway Actor (Play or Musical) and the next person casts them in the perfect role that is suited for them in any play or musical.

I'll go first:

Laura Benanti

[AC126748]

Rosa Bud in The Mystery of Edwin Drood

Sherie Rene Scott

[LaurenElizabeth41]

Mama in 'Night, Mother

Norbert Leo Butz

[wickedfan11]

Moonface Martin in Anything Goes

Patti LuPone

[frazer]

Have always thought for some reason she'd make a great Aunt Eller in Oklahoma.

Adam Kantor

[random person 112]

i really want to see him play young buddy in follies for some weird reason.
Vanessa Williams?

[AC126748]

I've always harbored a desire (no pun intended) to see her as Desiree.

Sara Ramirez

[ILuv2shop531]

I could see her being a great Rosie in Bye, Bye Birdie

Krysta Rodriguez

[North2009]

Columbia in ROCKY HORROR.

Kevin Chamberlin

[ReggieonBway]

Brian in Avenue Q

Brian Stokes Mitchell

[random person 112]

Fredrick in a little night music maybe possibly to either audra mcdonald or vanessa williams desiree.
Jan Maxwell

[North2009]

Liza in LADY IN THE DARK

Brad Oscar

[frazer]

Albin in La Cage

Brian D'arcy James

[North2009]

Harold Hill

Judy Kaye

[frazer]

mrs. wilkinson in Billy Elliot

Chris Sieber

[North2009]

Applegate in DAMN YANKEES

Tammy Blanchard

[random person 112]

Janet in the rocky horror picture show.
Emily Skineer.

[frazer]

Diana - Next to Normal

Mark rylance

[shrekster224]

Sorry it's not a direct reply, but to Laura Benanti, although it wouldn't be perfect, I would love to see her take on Diana. And Norbert as Moonface sounds great!

[BeingAlive2]

Mark Rylance in Death of a Salesman

Audra McDonald?

[quizking101]

Audra McDonald as Mother Superior in SISTER ACT.

Next Star: Hunter Ryan Herdlicka

[random person 112]

Maria in the sound of music vocally perfect and to all those who would say audra would be wrong due to the fact she's african american, the sound of music is anything but entirely factual.
Julie Andrews?

[aasjb4ever]

Hunter Ryan Herdlicka as Woof in Hair

ETA: Rory O' Malley

[BeingAlive2]

Julie Andrews: Madame Armfeldt / Rory O'Malley: Jack in Into the Woods

Hannah Waddingham?

[random person 112]

In twenty years carlotta in follies, but i could also see her as mrs. lovett in sweeney, or jenny in company.
Angela lansbury?

[madbrian]

Lansbury: Berthe in Pippin

Next: Diana DeGarmo