I have always liked that NYC lyric ended on "tough". People who hate New York say it's big, loud and tough. Here, it's the city's virtues. "Proud" would be WRONG.
I hate to jump on the William Finn bandwagon because I do love his work, but in "the I love you song", I always thought 'we always knew you were a champion, your sadness filled my room, dear if you should feel my gloom blame it on me" was a bizarre and unclear phrase; perhaps it's going over my head somehow.
oliva, I love Finn, but I wrote a few pages back that he tends to let his rhyming lead him by the nose through a lyric. The lines you quote seem like an example.
joined:3/30/12
Posted: 8/30/12 at 10:00pm