My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review - Carnival Round The Central Figure

By:

The central figure of Diana Amsterdam's tragedy of manners is a young, terminally ill accountant named Paul (Ted Caine) who spends most of the evening silently lying in a hospital bed surrounded by a carnival of denial. Unable to communicate, it's unclear how much of his wife, Sheila's (Christine Rowan), mask of perkiness he must endure as she forces positive energy into the room with plans for their future and uses an annoyingly motherly tone to praise the fact that he ate a whole half a banana today and kept it all down.

Her antics are all rather distasteful to Paul's co-worker Kate (Danni Simon) who comes for a visit and, sounding like the voice of the playwright, insists that Sheila but blunt with Paul about the fact that he is dying.

Their scenes in Carnival Round The Central Figure alternate with snippets from a televised gospel program, Speak Straight to Jesus, that features a fanatically energetic evangelist (Shane LeCocq), backed up by a frenzied choir, reminding us that death is simply the passing from this world into the next.

While Amsterdam offers a promising set-up, the playwright never goes much beyond stating the fact that people generally don't like to talk openly about death. At times she even appears critical of faiths that comfort their followers with the promise of an afterlife.

But while the text is too simple and repetitive, director Karen Kohlhaas' production for IRT keeps the evening visually interesting. The modest space is decorated with posters depicting a Mardi Gras skull and strings of light from above suggest we're seated under a carnival tent with an imposing nurse, who occasionally sucks blood out of Paul with an enormous syringe, seated throne-like on a raised platform, observing actors who perform ritualistically in whiteface. The company dives into the material admirably but there just isn't enough there.

Photo Danni Simmons and Ted Caine by Deneka Peniston.

Click here to follow Michael Dale on Twitter.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Direction of a Musical - Top 3
1. Michael Arden - The Lost Boys
33.1% of votes
2. Tim Jackson - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
15.5% of votes
3. Lear deBessonet - Ragtime
10.6% of votes

Don't Miss a Off-Broadway News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Spirit of the Game: The Ultimate Musical in Off-Broadway Spirit of the Game: The Ultimate Musical
Asylum NYC (5/14-5/17)
New Owner in Off-Broadway New Owner
New Victory Theater (5/09-5/17)
WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at Bardavon in Off-Broadway WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at Bardavon
Bardavon 1869 Opera House (7/31-7/31)
LA CASA DE BERNARDA ALBA in Off-Broadway LA CASA DE BERNARDA ALBA
Repertorio (11/15-12/31)
MENAFEE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University in Off-Broadway MENAFEE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/25-7/25)
PAPER MENAGERIE | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon in Off-Broadway PAPER MENAGERIE | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon
Bardavon 1869 Opera House (7/19-7/19)
Hadid in Off-Broadway Hadid
59E59 Theatres (7/10-7/21)
bala.fruta./bullet.fruit | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist in Off-Broadway bala.fruta./bullet.fruit | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/11-7/11)
WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon in Off-Broadway WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon
Bardavon 1869 Opera House (8/01-8/02)
UNMOORED | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University in Off-Broadway UNMOORED | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/12-7/12)


Videos